Host: John Mulaney
Musical Guest: Phoebe Bridgers
John Mulaney returns to the ring for his seventh stint as SNL host. Can Kid Gorgeous score a knockout, or is the show down for the count?
Let’s find out at this week’s After Party.
Cold Open
In a rare, though not unheard of move, host Mulaney appears in this sketch where the CIA has gathered tech billionaires to teach them the difference between women who want to sleep with them and spies.
The tech titans start by asking when have they ever let the country down, and Mulaney says they did so Friday when the FAA had to ground domestic flights. They ask him to name another time, and he points to the nationwide Outlook outage earlier in the week. They ask him to name another time, to which Mulaney replies, “I’m done naming times!”
Mulaney then presents various Venn diagrams that show, for example, beautiful women and the men’s interests and opinions, with no overlap between the two circles.
Towards the end, Bowen Yang pops in as disgraced Nvidia head Jensen Huang, who states that “When you invite Jensen over, you know what’s about to go down. The S&P 500.”
This is a funny cold open that takes shots at all the familiar tech guys from Musk to Zuckerberg to Altman and Thiel. It is well-written, topical, and best of all, nary a moment of Trump bursting in.
We are off to a promising start!
Monologue
Mulaney takes command of the Studio 8H stage for his seventh time at-bat with a genuinely funny monologue about determining that his father and most boomers are on the spectrum.
He points to his dad’s attempts to make conversation by pointing out there’s garbage in John’s waste basket and adds “Do you know how far on the spectrum you have to be to rise to the rank of Eagle Scout?”
He also takes boomers to task for their criticism of younger generations. For example, he says the boomers like to complain about kids today having too much screen time, but then asks if people know how hard it is to take an iPad from a 78 year-old. “He’ll grip it like a strong gorilla at a good zoo.”
Mulaney transitions to talking about his kids’ friends and notes that there’s always one kid with a weird raspy voice, which lets him segue to RFK, Jr.
Mulaney is not comfortable with the HHS Director being “in charge of your bones and tummy.” He tells a story about when he knew RFK, Jr. from before he joined the administration. Mulaney had performed at a benefit RFK, Jr. hosted, A few days later he got a phone call from him and he thought he had been “butt dialed by the mom from The Goonies.”
This was a long, stand-up monologue. But, it fired on all cylinders. The studio audience clearly enjoyed it (even the musicians seemed to genuinely laugh for a change), and it certainly didn’t feel like it dragged.
After last week’s dire episode, this one is looking up. Way up.
Plane Crash
Ashley Padilla is an on the scene news reporter covering the crash of a plane inbound to New Jersey from Turkey. The first passenger interviewed (Mulaney) has an odd head bandage and makes up a weird story about how fire on the plane burned his head. It is obvious he has just returned from Turkey for a hair transplant. Other passengers emerge with other odd surgeries, and Mikey Day pops in as a very odd looking man who is hopeful that outbound flights have not been canceled.
This is an entertaining bit of fluff that relies mainly on silly sight gags as well as Mulaney’s amusing denials.
This one is affably funny.
Sister
In this pointed pre-taped commercial parody, Mulaney talks about how difficult it is to care for an elderly parent. Nursing care is expensive, but there’s a service that is reliable and free. That’s Sister. Your sister, who has been shaped by years of the patriarchy, will respond immediately and will take care of your parent while the menfolk go about their lives.
This manages to be funny and make a point with absolute precision.
It’s probably one of the smartest and funniest commercial parodies in a while.
Kathy
Padilla brings back her character Kathy, the person from the office that no one wants to talk to.
When a group of co-workers (Mulaney, Kenan Thompson, Day and Sarah Sherman) at a bar talk about what drinks they have, Kathy pipes up from another table, “We talkin’ drinks?”
They try to ignore her, but she goes on a rambling story about how a tick bit her when she was trying on pants at a garage sale, so her coconut drink (the ingredients of which she drones on about) also contains antibiotics.
The group keeps trying to ignore her when she butts in. At one point the group is talking about how they plan to travel home for Thanksgiving, and Kathy repeatedly says, “We talking’ transpo?”. Eventually the group ignores her long enough that she stops asking until they think she is gone, only to be caught by her at the end.
This is, on paper, a decidedly dumb sketch that should not have worked once, much less a second time. But, by jingo, it remains funny thanks almost entirely to Padilla’s outstanding performance. She is so annoying and dogged, and keeps it together so well that the bit just works.
Should this show up again? Not routinely, no. But once every season or two, I’d have no problem with this recurring character.
Gettin’ It Done
In a second pre-tape, Jeremy Culhane plays Chris Gut, a reality show on beer brewers.
In this episode, Gut meets up with the master brewer (Mulaney) at Stone Throw Breweries.
Basically, the two get buzzed and kiss. Then they are awkward for a while. Then they kiss again.
At one point, Gut finds some unlabeled beer bottles and notes “Some of these beers don’t have labels. Maybe nothing should.”
In the end, it turns out that they only kissed because they were drunk.
This sketch is oddly sweet and well executed. It’s not hilarious, relying mainly on the shock/laugh value of the kisses, but it is a good parody and goes through some interesting emotional turns.
Weekend Update
Che and Jost talk about the FAA flight shutdown, leading Jost to point out that “suddenly ferry transportation is looking pretty reliable.” He and former SNL cast member Pete Davidson, for some reason, own a Staten Island ferry.
Che talks about Jensen Huang, the Nvidia chief who was forced to resign after he was caught in a “honey trap” by an apparent Chinese spy. Che tells us that the term honey trap comes from the person who invented it, a pimp by the same name. He adds that the scandal has been so bad for the stock market that you might lose your house because of Huang’s divorce.
They discuss Trump’s desire to topple Cuba’s Communist regime, which is odd as he can’t topple America’s (showing a photo of recently elected left-wing candidates), and we hear about a new Biden memoir looking back on his presidency, leading to the joke that “so now he remembers his time as President?”
The single desk guest this week is Tommy Brennan who performed a song about family members on Thanksgiving. Although Brennan seems to stumble a couple of times, the song is cute and funny, and is punctuated by a great story by Brennan about when his sister came out to the family.
Central Park Horse & Carriage Ride
What would a Mulaney SNL episode be without a Broadway show tune parody sketch?
In this offering, Mulaney is a Central Park carriage driver who is giving one of his last rides to Marcello Hernandez and Kam Patterson before a ban on the carriages goes into place.
Mulaney offers to show them the Little Park of Horrors (leading some park critters to sing that song).
Then a woman who is still finishing the marathon (Veronika Slowikowska) sings a version “Don’t Rain on My Parade” (and brings down the house!).
Next, Brennan shows up as Mulaney’s bitter enemy, a Pedicab driver. The two then sing “Anything You Can Hit, I Can Hit Better”
We get a song based on Cats from a haze of weed, “I just met a boy named Mamdani”, and Bowen Yang as the Mary Todd Lincoln tunnel parodying a Dream Girls number. (Yang is currently appearing in the title role in Oh, Mary! on Broadway).
We even get a callback/cameo from Kathy as, after all, they are talkin’ about transpo.
The whole thing ends with a parody of songs from Hair with “The Age of Equis” and “Let the Horse Ride.”
These sketches are always fun and admirable. This may not have been the best one to date, but it’s still highly entertaining and an outstanding sketch. Mulaney is just so good at these things. They are well produced and performed, and it makes you wonder how they have time to prep much of anything else for the show.
Woodstock
Speaking of the Age of Aquarius, Woodstock attendees talk about peace, love and happiness as one of their numbers (Mulaney) makes comments like “When we get older, we should buy all the houses and just have them.” He suggests the same thing about money.
When told that “our whole thing is about sharing and generosity,” he says everyone should do a 180 in 1985 and tell kids that weed and everything they enjoy will “kill them stone ass dead.”
He also says that come 1985, they should all just turn Republican.
This is a barbed sketch that gets big laughs while also making strong social criticism, which this episode has done well. (See, e.g., Sister).
The Goodbye Wave
Best Sketch: What an enormously difficult call. I could make a case for almost any of them this week. But, even if it wasn’t the best iteration of this, the musical parody, Central Park Horse & Carriage Ride gets the nod. These are just so well produced and entertaining that it’s hard not to applaud them.
Worst Sketch: I want to cop out and say, “none” this week, but I won’t. This week’s worst sketch could be the best sketch in many episodes. I’m going to go with Gettin’ it Done. But only because I had to pick something, and this one was more well done than funny. Again, however, calling this a “worst” sketch is blatantly unfair.
Random Notes:
- The sketch count here was low. Mulaney had a long (and funny) monologue, and overall the sketches seemed longer than usual (most notably the musical parody). Often I might complain about sketch length, but not here. This episode just worked.
- Mulaney was in every sketch of the night, which is unusual. Generally, the host doesn’t appear in the cold open, and they may not even be in all the other pieces. But if you got Mulaney, you use that guy.
- Has there ever been an instance of a character from an earlier sketch popping up in a later sketch? Let me know if you can think of any.
- Phoebe Bridgers had some interesting visual effects in her second number.
This was - by far - the best episode of the season. Mulaney is a talented host and writer and the show perks up anytime he is involved.
Credit Bowen Yang with an assist here as it was genuinely great seeing him on the SNL stage again.
This episode is the shot in the arm this flagging season needed. And, it wasn’t just great by this season’s dubious standards. It was an overall great episode.
Grade: A.
As always, we grade SNL episodes in comparison to other SNL episodes. Not TV in general. If you want to support our content, consider subscribing on Substack